Independent supplement ratingsUS and Canada · Updated weekly
New Fitness Supplements — independent supplement ratings

A ratings desk for a category that has spent thirty years grading its own homework.

HomeRatingsMagnesium
Category ranking · 6 products rated

Best magnesium supplements

We ranked every magnesium supplement we could verify on one scale: the elemental dose against the range used in research, the form and its absorption, third-party testing, verified reviews, and price per serving.

Method v2.1Recalculated 12 Jul 2026Written by the NFS editorial team
Magnesium
Scores combine ingredients and dosing (40%), verified user reviews (35%) and price per serving (25%). The same weights apply to every product. See how we rate →
Our top pick NOW Foods Magnesium Citrate
NOW Foods
Citrate · 120 capsules
Clinical doseNo third-party test
400mg elemental / 200–400mg studied
9.3
out of 10
$0.31 / serving
2
Doctor's Best
Glycinate/lysinate chelate · 240 tablets
Clinical doseGreat value
200mg elemental / 200–400mg studied
9.0
/ 10
$0.20 / serving
3
Nature Made
Oxide · 200 tablets · one a day
Real elemental doseCheapest per serving we foundOxide — poorly absorbed
250mg elemental / 200–400mg studied
8.2
/ 10
$0.05 / serving
4
Thorne
Glycinate · powder, 60 servings
Clinical doseThird-party tested (NSF)
200mg elemental / 200–400mg studied
7.6
/ 10
$0.78 / serving
5
Pure Encapsulations
Glycinate · 180 capsules
Clinical dosePremium price
120mg elemental / 200–400mg studied
7.2
/ 10
$0.26 / serving
6
BiOptimizers
7-form blend · 50 capsules
Broad-formDoses not split out
Total 500mg / per-form dose undisclosed
6.8
/ 10
$1.36 / serving

How we scored this category

Two things decide most of the score: the form and the elemental dose. Oxide is cheap and poorly absorbed; glycinate and citrate absorb well and sit behind most of the research on sleep, cramps and stress. A label that lists “500mg magnesium” tells you nothing until you find the elemental figure — that is the number our dose bar tracks.

What drops a product down the list

Prices are checked at publication and re-checked monthly. Where a brand changed its formula and we could not re-verify the new label, we say so rather than guess. Read the full method →